How to separate "talent" from "coaching"

[fredtoast]

(09-08-2021, 01:05 AM)tms Wrote:  In fact, his PFR Approximate Value in 2019 was equal to Brady's in 2020 (15)- again, despite the interceptions. It stands to reason that intangibles had a far more significant influence on the Bucs' outcomes than just one isolated statistic.

Actually what "stands to reason" is that whatever "PFR Approximate Value" measures does not have a lot to do with winning games.

2019 Winston...... 60.7 comp%..... 33 td..... 30 int.....   84.3 rating..... 12 fumbles
2020 Brady.......... 65.7 comp%..... 40 td..... 12 int..... 102.2 rating.....   4 fumbles