ranking Bengals Qb's

[TecmoBengals]

(08-08-2022, 10:29 AM)Speedy Thomas Wrote: I'm having trouble compiling a list.  Are we ranking over the course of a career?  Over a season?   Personal favorite?  Do we limit it to players we have seen?  Here's what I got:

Best QB over a career -- Ken Anderson
Biggest "what-if" QB -- Greg Cook
Most under-appreciated QB -- Andy Dalton
Best left handed QB -- Boomer
Worst left handed QB -- Gus Frerotte
Best QB at throwing moon balls to Carl Pickens -- Jeff Blake
Best QB at almost getting killed behind an even worse offensive line than last year's -- David Klingler
Best nickname -- Jack Thompson, "The Throwin' Samoan"
Best chest-thumper -- Akili Smith
Best QB at being a better coach than he was a QB -- Sam Wyche
Best prime-time smirk by a QB -- Ryan Finley
QB I want for one game to win it all -- Joe

I mostly used the entirety of a career for my ranking framework, but made an exception for Burrow and bumped him to #3. I suppose if we're looking at career stats and longevity then he's after Kenny, Boomer, Dalton, Palmer, Blake, and perhaps even Kitna. If it's only talent, he might be #1.