03-17-2023, 01:39 PM
(03-17-2023, 12:36 PM)Frank Booth Wrote: drop the pro bowl argument. It's complete crap. Justin Smith made zero pro bowls in cincy. Whitworth made 2.
it's a popularity contest/best team contest
You overstate things, per the usual. And all the other stuff still stands.
Yes, sometimes deserving players don't make the PB. But Jonah isn't Whit. Or Reader. Are you saying you think Jonah is a Pro Bowl caliber player? Feel free, but that is laughable in my view.
And of course the Whit argument is the opposite of the Brown argument. It is one thing for deserving guys to get left off, quite another for undeserving guys to make it. And I am not talking Andy Dalton 3rd injury replacement making it, I am talking getting voted on the first time. Which Brown has. He's a top 6-7 OT in the league. Not top 3, granted. But top tier. Top 10. Consistently good.
