Jonah Williams Requests Trade

[*ochocincos*]

(04-10-2023, 04:32 PM)Frank Booth Wrote: I want to bring up some facts and logic for you to try and refute, but you'll prob just ignore them and rely on your feelings. But I'll try and talk with you...

Explain how a league average starting LT will lose to a completely banged up Collins(who wasnt good at RT anyways in 2022 when he had less health problems), 

and explain how he will lose to Carmen, despite Carmen being bad his whole tenure except for the buffalo game

go ahead and explain without your feelings

This wasn't to me, but I'll respond.

Some people (not me) think that Jonah will be worse at RT than LT, where he has been serviceable prior to 2022.
They don't know that for certain, they are making an assumption/guess.

As for Carman, he only allowed 1 total pressure (1 sack) in the 32 snaps at OT this year prior to the Buffalo game.
In the Buffalo playoff game, he allowed 3 total pressures with 0 sacks.
He performed exactly the same in the KC playoff game. 3 total pressures, 0 sacks.

If Carman performed a full season at LT like he did in the 3 playoff games (1 sack, 7 total pressures), he'd have ~6 sacks allowed, ~40 total pressures.
That's better than what Jonah did last year (12 sacks, 43 total pressures) and 2021 (8 sacks, 43 total pressures), but not a crazy improvement.


Let's not act though like Carman would be perfectly fine handling RT but Jonah wouldn't. Carman hasn't been playing RT either. We'd be looking for two LTs and an OG to transition (back) to RT. Ford hasn't done much at RT since 2019 when he allowed 8 sacks and 35 total pressures in 449 pass blocking snaps. Jonah Williams played 724 pass block snaps in the regular season last year.

Ultimately, we got a bunch of unproven and/or bad players for RT while Collins is on the mend.
Jonah - hasn't played RT since college
Carman - hasn't played RT
Ford - last played primarily RT in 2019
Adeniji - lol
Smith - more lol

With all of that said, I do think Pollack has confidence in RT between Carman, Ford, and Jonah, at least as a stopgap until Collins is back healthy.