12-22-2023, 09:18 AM
(12-21-2023, 07:47 PM)Murdock2420 Wrote: I'm not going through this entire thread to check but I hope no one is placing Burrow or Chase or most anyone on the current team on the all time list yet.
If Chase goes down with a career ender is he still an all time great with under 4000 yards? Chad Johnson, AJ Green and Isaac Curtis have the career numbers that make them stand out. The recent bias is silly.
They actually changed the game when Curtis came along. People putting up all time teams that never saw half the players play is kind of a lame game anyway. They want to say Chase is the greatest WR ever on the Bengals, even though he doesn't have the numbers yet. But they do not mention Cook, because he didn't play long enough to get the numbers. Players like Tommy Casanova are rarely ever talked about. If you didn't see them all play, it's impossible to do the list. You can't go by numbers alone because the game has evolved so much. I've watched them ALL play, and I can't do the list because I forget some of them.
