Most Overrated Bengals

[Essex Johnson]

(01-31-2016, 10:15 PM)TheLeonardLeap Wrote: Ugh, now you've made it into a Steelers thing, so I am going to feel hella dirty typing this up... but you're still wrong.

Marvin Lewis: 13 years, 19 WR, 5 with 1,000+ career yards (26.3%), 1 with 3,000+ career yards (5.2%)
Mike Tomlin: 9 years, 9 WR, 5 with 1,000+ career yards (55.5%), 3 with 3,000+ career yards (33.3%)

It's not even close how much better the Steelers have been at drafting WR under Tomlin than the Bengals under Lewis. Also, Santonio Holmes was a 2006 pick, Tomlin took over in 2007, so that was a Cowher pick.

- - - - -

Also, you're seriously trying to argue that Hilton isn't better than Sanu? Hilton hasn't played one more year than Sanu. Both were drafted in 2012, so you're wrong there too.
TY Hilton: 283 / 4,413 / 24
Mo Sanu: 152 / 1,793 / 11

Plus... Sanu has averaged 4 TDs the last 2 years? 0 in 2015, and 5 in 2014.. averages to 4, somehow? It's 2.5.

Your post is filled with all kinds of wrong information and numbers from top to bottom.

I never said Sanu was better than Hilton but you called Sanu overrated and mentioned Hilton in a comparison .. not me... but i don;t see how you can compare the two.. Hilton is a #1 .. Sanu #2/3.  I don't see how Sanu is overrated when you look at this that way.. also you are comparing Hilton 4 year total to Sanu 3 year total... so you are using some misleading stats ...  put Sanu on a pass happy Indy team in place of Hilton and I will stand by his stats would not be that different than Hilton today....

As for Pittsburgh.. I focused on top 3/4 round picks and showed they had some real dudes, i will have to let go Reid , since you are correct he was Cowher draft.. but lets put in Archer in, he was drafted as a WR and did nothing.  The totals for Sweed 2nd round and Archer 3rd round are a combined 92 yards receiving.. hell even Jordan Shipley had 614 yards receiving.   

My main point was that Steelers have not drafted out of this world early in WRs either and I am correct
 that Wallace is only WR outside of Brown to have over 4,000 yards with Tomlin at the helm... 

So back at ya baby..