Top 5 Bengals Of All Time

[Essex Johnson]

(05-21-2016, 09:31 AM)StLucieBengal Wrote: Stats wise it's hard to replace chad for another WR.   That being said he wouldn't be on my list.   I would put james brooks on that list.   But in the same breath it's probably hard to put another RB over Dillon.  

Actually when you dig into the stats, it is clearly Curtis was a overall better wr when you adjust for playing in 1970s and 2000s passing league.

Curtis had a clear advantage in YPC and ratio of TDs thrown to catches.  For example I looked at 4 peak years for each player and Curtis averaged 40 percent of all TDs thrown , Chad averaged 28 percent of all TDs thrown.  For career Curtis averaged 17.1 YPC to 14.4 for Chad.

My Top Five would be

Munoz, Anderson, Riley, Curtis, Dillion ( put him on a average team during his career and he would be a HOF)