Andy top 5 qb of all time?

[BengalChris]

(07-12-2016, 06:21 AM)Jpoore Wrote: I never said that dalton had the alcolades that Brady hadbut at the same time he has one of the mt. Rushmore of coaches at his disposal and Andy dalton has as many yards as dalton and about the same completion percentage so like I said STAT WISE the argument could be made and if he wins 3 super bowls I could easily make the argument that he's a top 5 qb all around and I believe they will make at least 13 straight playoff appearances with the insanly talented team that they will have for the next 5 years at least

There's so much more to being an NFL QB than yards, and given the changes in NFL rules, which boost the passing game, it's hard to imagine how your conclusion could be arrived at. And, Marvin Lewis is so far from a Mt Rushmore coach that a rocket couldn't get him there.

Now, if your memory only extended back one year, then I could understand your post. Even arguing that Dalton is a top 5 current QB is going to be met with skepticism, if not laughter.