Andy Dalton and the QBR Floor Theory

[*Nately120*]

(07-08-2015, 02:21 AM)rfaulk34 Wrote: So basically, it comes down to "if".

If Dalton played in a weaker division, he'd be a better QB. 

ehhhh...

So why do people keep comparing Dalton to Wilson?  Wilson is in a division that has been as good as the AFC North almost as long as Dalton has been around.  Why not compare Dalton to Andrew Luck?  There have been years when the AFC South has boasted the 2 worst teams in football.

The Titans had 2 whole wins last season, the Texans had 2 whole wins the season before, and the Jaguars somehow managed to stink MORE than those 2 teams since Luck showed up.  You can't act like the AFC North is the most torturous place to be a QB without giving props to our last QB (who played in the AFC North when the Steelers and Ravens were arguably better), or without using the same "hard division" excuse to absolve Wilson.

There, pick on Andrew Luck for having an easy division.  Same with Tom Brady.  The Dolphins, Bills, and Jets have been all kinds of stank lately.  Funny how those two elite QBs are so lucky to be in bad divisions.  Lucky, eh?