Dalton or Luck?

[Brownshoe]

(10-01-2016, 01:29 AM)BengalChris Wrote: In all fairness to Luck he certainly hasn't had the talent around him that Dalton has had. Not saying that makes Dalton worse or better. The Bengals have a defense, the Colts really aren't close.

If Luck were the Bengals QB we'd be winning just the same. Of course, we don't get #1 overall picks either, so if you want to have a value grade on them Dalton has been the better value.

Dalton has had a better defense throughout his career, but he really didn't have anything other than Green until 2013 when Marvin Jones stepped up. 2014 is the obvious and 2015 he had really good weapons. Luck has had 2 good receivers and a good TE pretty much his whole career. Both haven't had good run games either. So it's not like Dalton had a lot more talent around him... If we did I don't think that we would have went 4-12 the year before he was drafted. Hell, we even lost our top 2 receivers from that year too.