Dalton or Luck?

[Essex Johnson]

(10-01-2016, 10:22 AM)rfaulk34 Wrote: Oh, i know. I've pointed that out many times. If you ask pretty much anyone, they will tell you that top to bottom, the Bengals have a much better roster than the Colts. A better coaching staff and system too. 

At this point, i wouldn't trade them straight up if offered, but just speaking hypothetically, in the exact same circumstances, i think Luck could do a little bit more. Most of it would have come in the early years though. It took Dalton a while to get where he is, whereas Luck came in able to put up bigger numbers.

If you compare their first two seasons, you are going to find similar numbers with edge to Luck in yards 256 to 220 a game but Andy had one more TD in those first two years 47 to 46.  So not a great difference between the first two years as far as stats.