Head coaching grades for all 32 current HC's

[Shake n Blake]

(10-14-2016, 03:37 PM)fredtoast Wrote: 1. Don't think a 10-6 division champion should be worth THREE TIMES as many points as an 11-5 wildcard team.  2. And I don't think an 8-8 division champion should be worth more than an 11-5 wildcard team.  Playing in a weak division has zero to dowith how good a coach is.

3. Also don't know why there should be a 6 point difference between a 7-9 team and a 9-7 team when there is only a 2 point difference between a 9-7 team and an 11-5 team.  4. To me all the 7-9 to 9-7 teams are all about the same while it is much more rare to win 11 games.

5. And finally, shouldn't a team that wins 11 games and makes the playoffs earn more points than a team that goes 10-6 and misses tha playoffs?

1. Win your own division. It's pretty important.
2. Which divisions are "good or bad" is subjective and has no place in an objective ranking.
3. Losing seasons are punished. Don't lose.
4. Sorry, I don't see 7-9 teams as the same as a 9-7 team.
5. Not sure what you mean. 11-5 WC team that is 1-n-done would be +5, while a 10-6 team that misses the playoffs would also be +5. Are those 2 seasons all that different? Was the 11-5 team that much more successful? Not IMO.

Edit: Just noticed that you think 7-9 and 9-7 teams are the same, but you blast the grading system for not separating 10-6 teams from 11-5 teams.