I feel bad for Andy

[fredtoast]

(12-26-2016, 05:00 PM)bfine32 Wrote: Ones most would agree on:

Ben
Drew
Tom
Aaron
Russell
Cam
Romo
Ryan
Luck
Stafford


Younger QBs making a case:
Winston
Matrrota
Carr
Prescott
Tannehill

Vets that could compare:
Eli
Rivers
CP9

So giving and taking benefit of the doubt; I'd put Andy 13-17 (middle of the pack)

Now list starting QBs that you think are clearly worse than Andy.

I don't see how you can say Luck, Newton, or Stafford are clearly better than Dalton, and Romo has not been good since '14.  Carr and Mariota deserve as much love as any of those guys, and I'd have Rivers ranked much higher. 

If you think Dalton is no better then 13 then why can't you say which 12 QBs are better?

I put Dalton in the 8-12 tange.  Not elite, but much better than just a "serviceable starter".