Good Andy/Bad Andy

[*Synric*]

(10-05-2017, 10:29 AM)THE PISTONS Wrote: Well his numbers show that he has been subpar or worse in 37% of his games. That's nearly 2 out of 5 games.

Cam Newton had 1 really great year when they went 15-1...then has been pretty bad since.

Andrew Luck has always been extremely overrated. I'd say in his prime, Carson Palmer is better than Luck.

But yeah...a garbage TD late in the game can skew passer rating. And sometimes a QB leads an epic drive only to have a RB score from the 1 thus the passer rating doesn't get the TD boost. But all things considered, this is a decent method to use to compare.

System is very important to passer rating also. A team that runs an high percentage west coast offensive (Jay Gruden) is likely to have a QB with a higher passer rating than a team that runs the deep passing Air Coryell (Bruce Arians)...

Just look at the difference in passer rating for Big Ben during the Arians era and the Haley era.