Abortion for undocumented teen? Pro-life gov official thinks not

[*bfine32*]

(10-25-2017, 02:13 AM)Dill Wrote: As already explained, Jane Doe's undocumented status is what put her under control of a pro life jailer.  So lack of US citizenship has something to do with that.  And that is why I called her "undocumented" in the title.

And as already explained, lack of citizenship and state laws do not affect the question of basic rights. So that's why no "cliff notes" on states rights.

There is no problem. The judge has ordered Jane Doe be allowed to have an abortion because that is her right under US Law, citizen or no.

She has the right to have an abortion; however, she must have parental consent.

I'll answer the cliff notes question as we've witnessed you do all you can to circumvent it.

Yes. The cliff notes to this situation is that a person should not be required to follow state law because they are an illegal immigrant.

You can argue the validity/rationale of the state law all you want; however, that does not change to essential matters in this case. If you truly disagree with this instead of simply posting a lot of words and using the bold feature arbitrarily. ask yourself: When was the last case in Texas that made National news because a 17 year old citizen's guardian did not concur with the girl's desire to abort her child.    

The 21st amendment lifted prohibition, does she have the right to drink

The 19th amendment granted women the right to vote. Could this girl vote even if she were a citizen?

If you answered no to either of these then ask your self one final question: Why did you answer no.