AJ McCarron Does It.

[jfkbengals]

(12-17-2017, 07:25 PM)Stonyhands Wrote: What evidence do you have that Dalton is better than McCarron?  You cannot deny that McCarron had the Steelers game won in the playoff before Hill fumbled.  We were never that close with Dalton at QB against any of the teams he faced in the playoffs.  That’s truth.  

MCCarron took the Bengals into overtime against the best defense in the NFL that dismantled Brady and embarrassed Cam Newton to go on and win the Super Bowl.  

People want to criticize McCarron and say he only won at Alabama because of his surrounding team and then the very same people make excuses for Dalton because of his surrounding team.  

McCarron has way better stats in college and is flat out a better QB than Andy is period, point blank.  Does that make AJ a hall of famer...no, but Andy is flat out garbage and would be out of this league if he played for any other team, like most of the garbage players in Cincinnati.

 You cannot deny that McCarron had the Steelers game won in the playoff before Hill fumbled.

Easy to deny.  Had he "had the game won" the fumble wouldn't have mattered, would it?  The team's winning percentage with AJM starting in the postseason is still 0%, which is no better than the percentage with Dalton. 

MCCarron took the Bengals into overtime against the best defense in the NFL that dismantled Brady and embarrassed Cam Newton to go on and win the Super Bowl. 

He went to overtime against the Osweiler led Broncos, but personally gave them the win with a fumbled snap.  Maybe Dalton finishes them off in regulation, lest you forget he was an early MVP candidate with the team that season.  We can't say.  Regardless, the Broncos won that game, not the Bengals.


McCarron has way better stats in college



That's some funny shit right there.  You think college numbers have somthing to do with NFL capability?  HOW does it impact anything?  But while it is a topic of conversation, how many of Dalton's teammates entered the NFL?  Virtually all of AJ's did.  Do you think that MIGHT just impact what their college resumes look like?

What a freaking joke.

Once again.  We can move on from Dalton, I won't care.  But to try and argue that AJ has outperformed him or is a better option is absolutely ludicrous.