04-11-2018, 08:10 AM
(04-10-2018, 05:36 PM)wolverine515151 Wrote: When you put weights on things like, completion % , yard, td , that is someone putting in there own beliefs on how much they should count. That is the definition of subjective. That is not an absolute truth but someone putting weights based on what they believe it should be. That is absolutely subjective.
It is more important that the input data be objective than the formula.
As long as the input data is objective than every QB is being compared equally. The problem comes when the input data is subjective i.e., "window size", "receiver adjustment", etc.
So if you feel the formulas is flawed then show comaprisons between QBs witha different formula. just don't use subjective input data. That is what makes the rankings less reliable.
So explain what is wrong with the current NFL pass efficiency rating and show where Dalton would stand compared to all other QBs with adifferent formula.
