Thread Rating:
  • 1 Vote(s) - 5 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
Head coaching grades for all 32 current HC's (updated)
#37
(05-21-2018, 07:52 PM)Shake n Blake Wrote: Explanation of grading:

A few years ago (on the old boards) - in response to a certain poster who claimed that Marvin Lewis was one of the most successful coaches - I created a grading system to compare Marv's entire tenure to how the rest of the teams fared over the same stretch. I graded each season and added all the points together. The grading system looked like this:

+8 points for 12-16 regular season wins
+5 points for 10-11 wins
+3 for a 9-7 season
0 points for 8-8
-3 for a 7-9 season
-5 for 5-6 wins
-8 for 4 or fewer wins

I added the following bonuses:

+10 for a division title
+10 for each playoff win
+50 for a Super Bowl title

For example, Marv accumulated +18 points in 2015 without winning a playoff game, while he got a -3 grade for 2017. A 9-7 team that fails to win it's division, but wins 1 playoff game would accumulate a +13 score. Championship teams usually rack up a +85 score or higher. Not a perfect system, but IMO it's fair. Obviously if you make a deep playoff run or win a title, you should be heavily rewarded. You can also rack up points by winning in regular season and capturing division titles.

The last 2 years, I finally took Berserker's advice, and make it more of a coach to coach comparison. In order to do this, I graded every single season by every single current Head Coach. Fortunately, Pro Football Reference has all the information I needed on each coach's page, as it made accumulating the grades go much faster. In order to make the grades fair for comparison, I took each coach's total career points and divided them by total years coached. So the grades are a per season average for their career.

So here's the grades:

UPDATED RANKINGS WITH NEW COACHES:

^ means the coach moved up in ranking
v means the coach moved down
= means they stayed the same, obviously


^ 1. Doug Pederson: +42.5 (2 seasons)
v  2. Bill Belichick: +31.9 (23 seasons with Browns, Pats)
=  3. Mike Tomlin: +21.3 (10 seasons)
v  4. Mike McCarthy: +20.1 (12 seasons)
v  5. John Harbaugh: +19.2 (10 seasons)
v  6. Pete Carroll: +18.4 (12 seasons with Jets, Pats, Seahawks)
v  7. Dan Quinn: +16.7 (3 seasons)
= 8. Sean Payton: +15.9 (10 seasons)
^ 9. Sean McVay +15 (1 season)
 10. Jon Gruden +14.2 (11 seasons with Raiders, Bucs)
v 11. Andy Reid: +13.2 (19 seasons with Eagles, Chiefs)
^ 12. Doug Marrone +11.0 (3 seasons)
^ 13. Mike Zimmer: +10.0 (4 seasons)
v  14. Ron Rivera: +9.2 (6 seasons)
v  15. Bill O'Brien: +7.8 (4 seasons)
v  16. Jim Caldwell: +7.6 (7 seasons with Colts, Lions)
v  17. Jason Garrett: +5.9 (7 seasons)
^ t18. Marvin Lewis: +3.0 (15 seasons)
^ t18. Anthony Lynn +3 (1 season)
^ t18. Sean McDermott +3 (1 season)
=  21. Jay Gruden: +0.5 (4 seasons)
v  t22. Adam Gase: 0 (2 seasons)
  t22. Frank Reich - Colts
  t22. Matt Nagy - Bears
  t22. Steve Wilks - Cardinals
  t22. Pat Shurmur - Giants
  t22. Mike Vrabel - Titans
v  28. Dirk Koetter: -1.0 (2 seasons)
v  29. Todd Bowles: -1.7 (3 seasons)
v t30. Kyle Shannahan -5 (1 season)
v t30. Vance Joseph -5 (1 season)
= 32. Hue Jackson -5.3 (3 seasons with Raiders, Browns)
_________________

Replaced coaches who didn't get another HC gig for whatever reason:

Chuck Pagano: +10.4 (5 seasons)
John Fox: +9.2 (16 seasons with Panthers, Broncos, Bears)
Bruce Arians: +8.3 (6 seasons with Colts, Cardinals)
Ben McAdoo: +5.0 (1 season) *Fired after 2-10 start that I didn't count in grade
Mike Mularky: +1.6 (5 seasons with Bills, Jags, Titans)
Jack Del Rio: +1.1 (14 seasons with Jags, Raiders)


(Old) Notes:

- This is not a ranking of who is the better coach, it's only meant to judge past success.
- I gave Arians credit for the 2012 Colts, when he coached 12 games with Pagano out.
- keep in mind that Marv's first 8 seasons featured as many 4 win seasons as playoff berths. That hurt his grade, but it happened.

Cool system and thanks for doing it. An idea I have is giving 10 point boost only once in the wild card/division round. That way if someone has a bye it makes a little more fair and realistic. So someone could win 2 games but only receive 10 points. Then maybe  20 points for winning the conference and adjust superbowl win to 40. Idk just an idea.
[Image: 4CV0TeR.png]
Reply/Quote





Messages In This Thread
RE: Head coaching grades for all 32 current HC's (updated) - TheUberHuber - 05-22-2018, 04:00 PM

Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 2 Guest(s)