Michael Knowles Slams Professor Claiming Columbus "Stole Land"

[BmorePat87]

So the professor's question is "How can one argue that descendants of indigenous tribes have no ancestral claim to land?" and the response back is that since some tribes warred with each other that there's no way that we can designated any land as belonging to one tribe.

This is irrelevant if the context of the debate is returning land from the American government (or any other government based on which nation we're having this conversation in). At that point you'd be discussing the land they had that was taken from them by the current government.

The point about differentiating between ethnicities is also a bit irrelevant. The discussion as far as I have seen is for land to return to sovereign tribes.

If we're asking "is subjugating groups of people and seizing land is immoral?", the answer is yes, no matter how many people have done it.

I find it hypocritical that Ben Shapiro would host this content considering his support for Israel.