Gun owner poll

[*bfine32*]

(10-04-2019, 12:57 AM)Dill Wrote: Sounds like a circular definition. 

How can you tell if a sacrifice is "successful"?  Ans: If it's "true."

How can you tell if it is "true"?  Ans: If it's "successful."

Custer made a "true sacrifice" you'd say?  Or an unnecessary one? The answer maybe gets us out of the circle

Same question for the Light Brigade.

I most likely doubt that....but I do see you keep changing the criteria. It's when from successful, to honorable, to unnecessary..who knows where it will go next.

Remember this all started with your questioning the success of King Leonidas' sacrifice and just kinda morphed from there. 

But my answer to your question remains unchanged. The "success" of a sacrifice is measured simply on the sacrifice. How dare you to call one unsuccessful.