04-30-2020, 02:47 PM
Andy is #3 for me. His longevity and the fact he played in a more pass happy league put his numbers higher than the others.....but Boomer was league MVP and Anderson led the league in passing, twice. Palmer in TDs once.
Andy never had the higher end talent those guys had. Yes, he made 3 pro bowls, but I think 2 of them were because other QBs got hurt. I put him ahead of Carson for being such a class act for so long. But I do not view him as a elite QB at any point. A good one? Yes. Elite? No.
Andy never had the higher end talent those guys had. Yes, he made 3 pro bowls, but I think 2 of them were because other QBs got hurt. I put him ahead of Carson for being such a class act for so long. But I do not view him as a elite QB at any point. A good one? Yes. Elite? No.
