10-21-2015, 10:46 AM
(10-21-2015, 10:43 AM)WhoDeyWho Wrote: Sure it does. Dude was a young QB. He wasn't a seasoned vet putting up those numbers. That's why I though the criticism was dumb. In the context of a young QB, his numbers were pretty damned good. That's why I could not understand all the hate. My guess is it had more to do with the playoff losses.
Sure it doesn't. You didn't even understand my post apparently, because your response is off the wall.
Andy playing well in 2015 doesn't mean the criticism for his mishaps in 2011 - 2014 weren't valid critiques. I'm not talking about the guys saying he's a dog shit QB that needs cut or the guys saying he'll never improve. The constructed criticism in say, 2012, was still warranted though he's playing at an elite level in 2015.
What's happening in 2015 could mean that predictions in 2012 were wrong, but it doesn't make analysis of what actually happened in 2012 "wrong". Get it? No. I insulted your baby, so you don't get it.
