Who is the Best Reds Player Ever?

[WeezyBengal]

(11-11-2017, 02:27 PM)McC Wrote: You wanna know why he isn't the best and still ranks behind the others?  Look at his post season stats, specifically 2012, when all they needed for three straight games was for somebody to drive in one more run and nobody did.  Nine post season games, 1 RBI.

The Big Red Machine drove in those runs, which is why they have the hardware and the recognition.  One word describes why he is behind them--clutch.

The only one of the big four from the Big Red Machine he can touch defensively is Rose and that's probably because Rose played so many positions.  And you do agree the game is half offense and half defense, right?

Just because it didn't happen yesterday doesn't mean it didn't happen.  There is no rewriting history just because you weren't there.

I rank him right behind Bench, Morgan, Rose and Perez and in a relative tie with Larkin.

So we're basing how good a player is all time based on the number of RBIs (a stat that many people this day discredit) he had in one series in the 2012 playoffs? Got it. 

And you go realize that Votto has won gold gloves, right?