Any complaints this week about Fat Randy?

[*TheLeonardLeap*]

(11-27-2017, 09:09 AM)Sled21 Wrote: Y'all raise up off the Nuge. He was a good kicker for a long time for us. He's gone now, no need to keep bashing him.

...but he wasn't? Nugent played for the Bengals from '10 to '16, and these were his FG% rankings...

'10: 21st
'11: 8th  (he had 14 FGs of 20-29 yards, aka shorter than a current PAT, and 0 attempts of 50+ that year)
'12: 20th
'13: 23rd
'14: 27th
'15: 23rd
'16: 24th

So the only year he wasn't a clearly below average kicker for the Bengals was the year he kicked a ton of PAT-FGs and didn't even bothering to attempt 50+.

He was actually really quite a bad kicker his entire Bengals career. I don't feel the need to keep bashing him for it, but I can't stay silent while people are calling his tenure with the Bengals "good".