Tier 3 QB

[*bfine32*]

(08-20-2018, 08:46 AM)fredtoast Wrote: One thing that is obvious is that the Bengals receiving corps was much better in '15 than in any other season.  It is obvious because of the team record 104.1 passer rating.

Another thing that is obvious is that in'15 Green, as well as the rest of the receiving corpse, was more productive with Dalton at QB than McCarron.

Green has his best playoff game in 2015 for the exact same reason that the Bengals passing game set so many other records that year.

So not really understanding what you mean by "dismissing" the obvious.  Unless it is "obvious" to you that the team record passer rating was thanks to McCarron's 4 games and 97 passer rating.  That seems to make sense to some people around here I guess.

So we know Green would have had his best playoff game every if Andy would have been the QB because of how he was performing in the regular season? You might get exactly 2 people to buy that, because throughout his career he has had a passer rating about 30 points lower in the playoffs then the regular season and he had never thrown a TD pass to AJ. 

But for some reason you expect folks to buy "it would have been different that year". Sorry but your fantasy does not over-ride reality. 

The obvious fact is AJ had his best playoff game with someone other than Andy Dalton at QB. You and others can come up with all kinds of other "reasons" and some are quite entertaining, but that's the obvious fact.

This was brought up simply because you made the ridiculous assertion that if we want to get rid of Andy because of poor playoff performances, we should also want to get rid of AJ. You may not be aware of this, but it's very hard for a WR to consistently put up good number when his QB is consistently shitting the bed.