01-20-2020, 04:27 PM
(01-20-2020, 04:23 PM)Shake n Blake Wrote: I still think Joe is the GOAT, or at least the most clutch QB of all-time. Sure, Brady has a longer resume (played forever, stayed with his legendary coach), but Joe's Super Bowl numbers will never be touched. 122 passer rating, 11 TD's to 0 picks.
Joe's playoff passer rating of 95.6 is much higher than Brady's 89.8 despite Joe playing in a much tougher era for passing. Joe's passer rating went UP in the playoffs while Brady's went down.
Not hating on Brady, but there are a lot of arguments for why Joe was more impressive. He also led a different team to a conference title game. He just didn't have Brady's longevity (partly due to the roughness of that era), nor did he get to stay with his original team/coach and rack up more rings, which I have little doubt he would have.
---------
To the OP, an elite QB can do a lot for us, but to be a title contender, we need good coaching and a more willing front office. Name the QB who did it all himself. It just doesn't happen. I love Burrow, but that kind of pressure shouldn't be placed on his shoulder's alone. We'll ruin him that way.
I'm going to name 1 Aaron Rodgers according to many football analytics people Mike Mccarthy is a horrible head coach.
