Rank the Bengal QB

[t3r3e3]

(07-13-2015, 04:06 PM)Luvnit2 Wrote: I believe once you get past 10 to 12 guys, then it becomes very subjective depending on the criteria.
If it now only and no eye for the future, some guys are obviously locks like Manning, Brees and Romo. But, for those who feel those guys have peaked and may soon decline, then Dalton could be considered the better next 5 to 10 year option.

I think he is closer to 16 than 20 for the mere reason when comparing the AD to others, I assume it is a straight trade and right now I would not trade Peyton for AD? I would have 2 years ago, but each year that goes by adds a nail to his retirement.

I'd make the Manning for Andy trade in a heartbeat. Especially given that the Bengals are under the cap. Imagine if the Bengals hadn't overpaid for Maualuga, and used that money and the cap cushion to theoretically sign Manning after a theoretical trade. The Bengals would instantly be the second favorite behind the Pats to represent the AFC in the Super Bowl. The question mark on d would be Dawson at MLB, but That is far outweighed by Peyton freaking Manning. We're speaking of one of the Top 3 QB's, all time. One year of Manning and a legitimate shot to win it all? Sign me up.