Geno Atkins and AJ Green HOF chances?

[McC]

(05-24-2017, 02:11 AM)Shake n Blake Wrote: A good comparison for Geno would be Cortez Kennedy (RIP). Kennedy made the HOF after racking up 58 sacks, but only made the playoffs once (with Kitna and Holmgren) and never winning a playoff game. If Kennedy was good enough for the Hall, why not Geno?

If a guy is being penalized for not winning a playoff game, the only thing that would counter it would be if the guy played well in the losses.  Without even looking, I gotta think very few Bengals have turned in stellar performances. 

To be fair, Geno didn't play in one and was still not himself yet in another.  AJ has missed two, if I remember right.  But has either turned in an all star performance in any of them?