07-10-2017, 08:10 PM
(07-09-2017, 10:36 PM)Essex Johnson Wrote: So again I just don't see your logic in your ranking of QB.. and downgrading more with playoff performance... it seems a bit twisted.. if a QB like Andy is getting to the playoffs but not performing well gets dropped for that over say a player that maybe has performed well with stats but say gets to playoffs maybe 1 time out of 5 years.. maybe they even win one game in playoffs ,, it seems that that QB that is getting to the playoffs year after year... is getting there because they have performed well in general in regular season or they would not even be in the playoffs.
I do believe Andy does get knocked back some for his playoff performance as he should.. maybe a couple spots but lets say he had the exact stats and overall win record but only made the playoffs 2 times.. and say was 0-2 in the playoffs would you have him higher in your ranking than you do being 0-4.
Its kinda like crapping on LeBron for making 8 finals because he could only win 3.
So would not making it at all have been better for his legacy?
If LeBron was 2-2 in the finals and was losing every year in the ECF would people want that more?
Not Dalton related but same family of criticism
