08-10-2017, 03:33 PM
(08-10-2017, 08:26 AM)muskiesfan Wrote: There is the constant argument that no one can hurl negativity at McCarron because there is not enough to judge him on. There's enough to want him to start, to say he's better than Dalton, to compare him to all-time greats and HOF QBs, but not enough to "unfairly" judge him or to contradict any of the previously mentioned positive thoughts. To question McCarron means you're a hater, stupid, or swinging from Dalton's ballsack. That's the general consensus I've learned from this board.
However, McCarron has a ton more playing time and tape than Driskel. Since Driskel is not McCarron though we can all automatically say he sucks and bash him and complain about how he doesn't deserve to share the same air as McCarron. Got it.
That's the thing with McCarron...he hasn't played enough to know if he's good or bad. From what I saw, he was more a game manager than a guy who's going to come out and through for 300+ yards on a regular basis.
I think for teams to trade a lot of assets for a guy that they want that big-armed guy who can win games by themselves. They want a guy that can be a Top 10-12 QB in the NFL.
I just don't see McCarron as that guy.
I see him as a guy that if he starts could end up somewhere in the 20-25th range for QB's.
