07-25-2018, 07:58 PM
(07-25-2018, 07:32 PM)YsCascadia Wrote: Your opinion is duly noted and is just as valid as my list is.
Let me ask you though, would you take winning 1 or 2 SBs with a QB that has Manning stats or would you rather have Marino or Rivers' stats and no SB?
Now Manning didn't just win 2 SBs due to defense and "breaks", he did it against the NE Patriots led by Belicheck and Brady who have only lost 3 of the 8 SBs they have been in. I would also argue that his 1st SB win was even more spectacular since they as a WC team went on the road to beat the NFC and then the 18-0 NE Patriots that you know wanted that perfect season more than anything.
I have never seen any other QB do that. Let alone any on this list.
He's overrated. He's on everyone's WORST QBS TO WIN A SB list, just like Marino is on everyone's BEST QBS NOT TO WIN A SB list.
You can have mediocre QBS win SBs because of the teams around them, I know I don't need to make a list, but Dilfer, Johnson, Flacco, and Namath come from the top of my head.
Marino never won a SB because he just didn't have the team around him.