I Shouldn't do this - but Im going to

[*ochocincos*]

(03-05-2019, 01:15 PM)Au165 Wrote: No, but Dalton is still a proven commodity Star or not. Sure another QB who can be a star is worth going for, not Rosen (Because I don't believe he is good). I'm just saying his year was historically bad. Brandon Weeden wasn't even that bad! If you told me they were going all in next year on Tua/Frohm/Herbet/etc I'd say go for it. If Rosen had all this star potential you wouldn't hear people saying he is worth a 3rd, Tyrod Taylor was traded for a 3rd. I think if he is moved it's for more than a 3rd eventually, but my point is if people believed he had all that potential we should be seeing more demand from NFL people. Starting QB's are hard to come by and to have one on the market on their first contract you should be seeing people offering a 1st plus....not a 3rd.

We are off in the weeds, so in an effort to get back on topic. I think you'd have to draft Risner before McGary to get both but I think you could get both in the 2nd.

A lot of the rookie QBs last year struggled. Rosen, Darnold, and Allen all only passed for low-2000's yardage, completion percentage in the 50's, and a near 1-1 TD-to-INT ratio. All could be bad, but they all went to bad teams who had mediocre-to-bad OLs and little-to-no help at WR.

As you said though, to get back on topic, I'd take Rosen over any QB in this year's draft class. If they don't trade for Rosen, I'd hope they wait until next year (or year after) to get their QB of the future. I agree that I think Risner has to be taken before McGary. Getting both would solidify the right side of the OL I think.