09-18-2019, 06:50 AM
(09-17-2019, 11:06 PM)rfaulk34 Wrote: Wow. This is a whole bunch of BS.
Dalton hasn't won a playoff game so, to now, no, he can't.
Foles was better than Dalton has ever been when he led the team to a SB win, in the same way Flacco was better than Dalton has ever been when he did the same thing. Neither QB is better, overall, as a QB than Dalton is, but they were better when the pressure was at its most.
If you really need to ask who is better because one has a SB ring and SB MVP, and one doesn't, you are completely lost. They're not mutually exclusive. Mahomes doesn't have the SB ring and SB MVP, but he doesn't need them to be the better QB.
What a wonderful way to not actually answer the question. Instead it is insinuating that I must not know the answer. I know the answer, but I am trying to find out how you rate them.
My position from the start is that there is no real such thing as a "better" QB just because one is "dynamic" (can run faster) than the other. However I have been told that Jackson (who only has a few games under his belt), Mahomes (who had a great season and a nice start, but hasn't had any adversity in WR dropping catchable passes, poor OLine play, injuries to himself and to those around him, defenses falling apart and bad coaching) are far better than Dalton (who went to the playoffs 4 years and out of those 4 only has 1 post season game where he could be accurately and fairly criticized, and the 5th year, his best, was injured prior to the start of the playoffs and never has had a chance to get back).
I haven't seen 1 argument that validates you position on rating QBs. Only that you think we should move on from Dalton because, to you, he is terrible. Anyone who doesn't agree with you are idiots. You haven't refuted 1 on my statements. All you have said was to "stop" doing it, because it irritates you.
