Confession of a Dalton Defender

[*PhilHos*]

(05-28-2015, 11:26 AM)bfine32 Wrote: 2 things:

1st: Although his rating dipped in year 4 it is still 11 points higher than it was as a rookie. Andy's is around 5.

First off, Andy's is around 3 (80.4 in year 1 to 83.5 in year 4). Might want to get your facts straight if you want to be taken seriously. Just sayin'.

Secondly, Peyton had a higher drop from year 3 (94.7) to year 4 (84.1) than Dalton (88.8 to 83.5). So :tongue:

Lastly, the point that YOU made was that one "would expect someone that was forced to start from year one to drastically increase by year 4". Peyton did not. Ergo, the same said about Dalton should be said about Peyton after year 4.

(05-28-2015, 11:26 AM)bfine32 Wrote: 2nd: Peyton had already shown the potential to be elite. he was the 4th rated QB in year 2 and 6th rated in year 3.   Hell, the year he "dropped" he was tied for 8th. In that same 3 year span of his career Andy has been rated; 13th, 15th, and 25th.

You're a bright guy. Which one of those 2 shows signs of a more promising career?

Oh, is that what we were arguing about? I thought it was about how QBs are not supposed to be worse in their 4th season than in their previous 2. My bad. <_<