+- Cincinnati Bengals Message Board / Forums - Home of Jungle Noise (https://thebengalsboard.com)
+-- Forum: Cincinnati Bengals / NFL (https://thebengalsboard.com/forum-3.html)
+--- Forum: JUNGLE NOISE (https://thebengalsboard.com/forum-2.html)
+--- Thread: Was it just me???? (/thread-17209.html)
Was it just me???? - Tlawsonmariat82 - 09-23-2018
2nd and 17 one play before dalton's first int,was it just me or was that really a catch by a.j green right before going out of bounds???
Why didn't we challenge this play??To me this makes the ensuing third down call much more manageable and at the very least maybe we don't turn the ball over right there,anyways that entire sequence just confused me....
RE: Was it just me???? - rfaulk34 - 09-23-2018
(09-23-2018, 08:29 PM)Tlawsonmariat82 Wrote: 2nd and 17 one play before dalton's first int,was it just me or was that really a catch by a.j green right before going out of bounds???
Why didn't we challenge this play??To me this makes the ensuing third down call much more manageable and at the very least maybe we don't turn the ball over right there,anyways that entire sequence just confused me....
Looked like a catch, but if you challenge again...even if you're successful, you only get 1 more the rest of the game. If it's questionable and doesn't get overturned, you're out of challenges.
RE: Was it just me???? - Tlawsonmariat82 - 09-23-2018
True...didn't realize we were just successful on a challenge with a.js other catch...
RE: Was it just me???? - GreenCornBengal - 09-23-2018
I don't believe you can call challenges on back to back plays. That was my rationalization. Couldn't challenge even if we wanted to.
RE: Was it just me???? - Sweetness - 09-23-2018
If I had to guess AJ bobbled the ball as he was going out of bounds. I didnt see anyone on the Bengals upset about it
RE: Was it just me???? - Dean_Gilberry95 - 09-23-2018
It looked like when he was getting up, the ball was at his waist and on the ground. It looked like he completed the the”process” of the catch. As he was getting up the ref signaled incomplete. Even walking back to the huddle he had his hands up like wtf?
RE: Was it just me???? - Tlawsonmariat82 - 09-23-2018
Just watched it again it was a clear catch even a.j looked confused as i was,the announcers didn't even realize it was ruled incomplete...
RE: Was it just me???? - bengaltruth - 09-24-2018
(09-23-2018, 08:34 PM)rfaulk34 Wrote: Looked like a catch, but if you challenge again...even if you're successful, you only get 1 more the rest of the game. If it's questionable and doesn't get overturned, you're out of challenges.you still challenge. period. dumb not to
RE: Was it just me???? - treee - 09-24-2018
Yea that play was WTF. He took like 5 steps before he went out of bounds with the ball. Those refs were pretty crappy today with the missed and incorrect calls.
RE: Was it just me???? - Pat5775 - 09-24-2018
(09-24-2018, 07:21 AM)treee Wrote: Yea that play was WTF. He took like 5 steps before he went out of bounds with the ball. Those refs were pretty crappy today with the missed and incorrect calls.
Wasn't it John parry's crew?
We lost this game before it even started
RE: Was it just me???? - SHRacerX - 09-24-2018
I was telling my dad they forgot to mark the yardage for the catch? I was like "he made it past the original LOS, not the current LOS...it was an 8 yard catch".
Didn't even see them call it incomplete. And that is typical NFL for Bengals...call it incomplete, make the Bengals challenge it to overturn, not the other way around.
RE: Was it just me???? - TKUHL - 09-24-2018
The ref was signaling out of bounds, Green had the wtf look but the announcers didn't say anything. I thought it was a catch but I also though his TD was too so.
RE: Was it just me???? - Tlawsonmariat82 - 09-24-2018
I wish marvin would've challenged that call,I think that particular sequence changed momentum because that int the next play was a forced throw...
3rd and 17 - Arturo Bandini - 09-24-2018
Well, I still don't understand why AJ's catch wasn't good along the sideline and I didn't see on TV why it went back to 3rd and 17.
Anyone can explain me what happened there ?
RE: 3rd and 17 - Lionel Hutz - 09-24-2018
Yeah, I was going crazy over this. Don't know how that call was missed, and the announcers were talking about everything other than what was happening on the field. Gotta wonder why Marvin didn't challenge? I know he had just used one, but he was successful on that challenge. 3rd and 9 obviously a lot more doable than 3rd and 17.
RE: Was it just me???? - sandwedge - 09-24-2018
(09-24-2018, 08:35 AM)TKUHL Wrote: The ref was signaling out of bounds, Green had the wtf look but the announcers didn't say anything. I thought it was a catch but I also though his TD was too so.
He clearly dropped the TD catch. He caught the one on the sidelines though.
RE: Was it just me???? - rfaulk34 - 09-24-2018
(09-24-2018, 07:13 AM)bengaltruth Wrote: you still challenge. period. dumb not to
You challenge. At the time, without hindsight, i said..."nah, 8 yards isn't worth it at this point in the game".