+- Cincinnati Bengals Message Board / Forums - Home of Jungle Noise (https://thebengalsboard.com)
+-- Forum: Cincinnati Bengals / NFL (https://thebengalsboard.com/forum-3.html)
+--- Forum: JUNGLE NOISE (https://thebengalsboard.com/forum-2.html)
+--- Thread: Will helmet to helmet become reviewable (/thread-4452.html)
Will helmet to helmet become reviewable - fisherscatfan - 01-10-2016
Similar to college? The non call on the hit on Bernard was huge. The right call is made and its first down, possibly first and goal. The NFL acts like it is serious on limiting concussions yet "miss" this call. That no call possibly led to the escalation and loss of control.
No mistake, the Bengals cannot get those PF calls at the end, but the Bernard no call was atrocious and cost the Bengals at least 3 or 7 points in a two point loss.
RE: Will helmet to helmet become reviewable - Housh - 01-10-2016
For about 4-5 years Iv witnessed that call become basically a way for refs to legally screw us
If they make helmet to helmet reviewable I believe no other team but us will benefit more
And that's why it won't become reviewable
RE: Will helmet to helmet become reviewable - PApinhead - 01-10-2016
It most certainly should be reviewable, but like Housh says, the NFL won't because it will take away their ability to influence games.
RE: Will helmet to helmet become reviewable - xxlt - 01-10-2016
(01-10-2016, 05:11 AM)fisherscatfan Wrote: Similar to college? The non call on the hit on Bernard was huge. The right call is made and its first down, possibly first and goal. The NFL acts like it is serious on limiting concussions yet "miss" this call. That no call possibly led to the escalation and loss of control.
No mistake, the Bengals cannot get those PF calls at the end, but the Bernard no call was atrocious and cost the Bengals at least 3 or 7 points in a two point loss.
What really made me mad was the announcers AND the NFL former official commenting numerous times it was the right call because Bernard was a runner and not a defenseless receiver. So to be clear, according to them, you can lead with your helmet and hit helmet to helmet all day long against anyone EXCEPT a defenseless receiver. Is that how anyone else understands the rule?
I thought neither runner nor tackler could lead with helmet and helmet to helmet hits were always a penalty since 2013 rule change.
RE: Will helmet to helmet become reviewable - BengirlVal - 01-10-2016
It needs to be reviewable! Gio was freaking knocked out cold! If that was reviewed it would have been a game changer!
RE: Will helmet to helmet become reviewable - Emphasis - 01-10-2016
Helmet to Helmet absolutely should never be allowed. And yes, the announcers for this game were nothing short of terrible.
RE: Will helmet to helmet become reviewable - Interceptor - 01-10-2016
(01-10-2016, 05:11 AM)fisherscatfan Wrote: Similar to college? The non call on the hit on Bernard was huge. The right call is made and its first down, possibly first and goal. The NFL acts like it is serious on limiting concussions yet "miss" this call. That no call possibly led to the escalation and loss of control.
No mistake, the Bengals cannot get those PF calls at the end, but the Bernard no call was atrocious and cost the Bengals at least 3 or 7 points in a two point loss.
![[Image: ref.png]](http://i397.photobucket.com/albums/pp60/nestminder/ref.png)
RE: Will helmet to helmet become reviewable - Housh - 01-10-2016
Mike Carey is trash and the announcers at heart thought it was a penalty. You can tell because of the tone they took while talking about it. It was obvious to anyone whose studied human behavior that they were being forced to act like they thought the no call was right. They took the exact same tone of sadness when Burfict and Jones got those 2 penalties at the end of the game
Definitely a NFL, WWE moment