If you HAD to pick one draft, which would it be and why.

[TKUHL]

Say you had to pick one of the following drafts. Which would you choose and why. I know the draft position in drafts 3 & 4 are not correct. Some sites only have one pick each round for all teams. No comp picks.

Draft #1. ……………… Draft #2
18. Bowers, B ………………. 18. Newton, J
TE Georgia. ……………… DT Illinois

49. Nubin, T ………………. 49. Legette, X
S Minnesota ……………….. WR South Carolina

80. Frazier, Z. ……………… 80. Frazier, Z
C West Virginia ……………… C West Virginia

115. Davis, T. ………………. 115. Sinnott, B
DL Clemson ………………. TE Kansas St

147. Foster, J ………………… 147. Jones, C
OT Missouri ………………… OT Texas

174. Holker, D …………………. 174. Taylor, T
TE Colorado St ………………… P Iowa

195. Simpson, J ………………… 195. Pritchett, N
CB Auburn ………………… CB Auburn

234. Ulofoshio, E …………………. 234. Ulofoshio, E
LB Washington ………………… LB Washington

251. Cephus, J …………………. 251. Okie, E
WR UTSA …………………. Edge Michigan



Draft #3 …………………… Draft #4
18. Latham, JC …………………… 18. Fuaga, T
OT Alabama ……………………. OT Oregon

49. Sweat, T …………………….. 49. Kitchens, K
DT Texas …………………….. S Miami

80. Stover, C …………………….. 80. Wilson, J
TE The Ohio St ………………………. WR Florida St

111. Elliss, J ……………………….. 111. Fiske, B
DE Utah ……………………….. DL Florida St

142. Davis, T ………………………… 142. Lloyd, M
DT Clemson ………………………… RB USC

178. Vaki, S …………………………. 178. Wingo, M
S Utah …………………………. DT LSU

209. Jurgens, M …………………………… 209. Taylor, T
C Wake Forest ……………………………. P Iowa

[Whatever]

If I had to pick one, I would say #1 after reconsidering. Bowers is a slam dunk perennial All Pro type player.

[puddycat]

Ignoring FA, #3 - these players almost all have a chance to make the team and enough upside to contribute, although TBO Latham makes me nervous.
#1 & #4- not interested in pulling the plug on the Dax Hill experiment with a 2nd round safety, or ignoring bad Day 3 picks.
#2 best if Tee is gone and RT was signed in FA.

[*bfine32*]

(01-27-2024, 11:47 PM)TKUHL Wrote: Say you had to pick one of the following drafts. Which would you choose and why. I know the draft position in drafts 3 & 4 are not correct. Some sites only have one pick each round for all teams. No comp picks.

Draft #1.           ………………                                  Draft #2
18. Bowers, B    ……………….                                 18. Newton, J
TE Georgia.        ………………                                  DT Illinois

49. Nubin, T       ……………….                                 49. Legette, X
S Minnesota       ………………..                               WR South Carolina

80. Frazier, Z.     ………………                                80. Frazier, Z
C West Virginia   ………………                                C West Virginia

115. Davis, T.     ……………….                                115. Sinnott, B
DL Clemson        ……………….                               TE Kansas St

147. Foster, J     …………………                              147. Jones, C
OT Missouri        …………………                               OT Texas

174. Holker, D    ………………….                             174. Taylor, T
TE Colorado St    …………………                              P Iowa

195. Simpson, J  …………………                             195. Pritchett, N
CB Auburn          …………………                               CB Auburn

234. Ulofoshio, E ………………….                              234. Ulofoshio, E
LB Washington     …………………                             LB Washington

251. Cephus, J     ………………….                            251. Okie, E
WR UTSA             ………………….                            Edge Michigan



Draft #3              ……………………                           Draft #4
18. Latham, JC     ……………………                          18. Fuaga, T
OT Alabama         …………………….                          OT Oregon

49. Sweat, T        ……………………..                         49. Kitchens, K
DT Texas              ……………………..                          S Miami

80. Stover, C        ……………………..                         80. Wilson, J
TE The Ohio St     ……………………….                        WR Florida St

111. Elliss, J         ………………………..                      111. Fiske, B
DE Utah               ………………………..                      DL Florida St

142. Davis, T        …………………………                      142. Lloyd, M
DT Clemson          …………………………                     RB USC

178. Vaki, S          ………………………….                       178. Wingo, M
S Utah                  ………………………….                        DT LSU

209. Jurgens, M    ……………………………                      209. Taylor, T
C Wake Forest       …………………………….                     P Iowa

#1- Because it has Bowers. Picking best from all 4:

Bowers
Sweat
Wilson
Elliss
Jones
Vaki
Jurgens

[WhoDeyK]

I’d really like a RT in round one but I think Latham has by far the biggest bust potential of any of these 1st round pick options so that eliminates 3 for me. Really like Fuaga so I’d be tempted by 4 but I think I’d go with 1. Bowers is the best talent in all of these options. I’m sick of spending picks on the defensive secondary, I don’t think the solution is going even younger and giving up on Dax at Safety, that said Nubin is a good player. Frazier and Davis are solid players and Foster would be a great value.

[Hammerstripes]

That's easy - The one with Bowers. I'll take the top 5 talent even though the 2nd round pick is a waste.

[SunsetBengal]

Not knowing how free agency will turn out, I vote for #3. It's not flashy, but addresses the line on both sides twice, as well as TE. Would like to have seen a RB or WR in there, but I guess we must have addressed those in free agency.