Future of the Kickoff/Punt

[Bengalstripes9]

I don't mind the new kickoff rule, but I could see some issues with offsides being called/not called when it should be.

I actually think it would make the game more interesting to do away with kickoffs and punts and force teams to go for it on 4th down.

It would make the game more entertaining.
Defense would become more of a factor because it makes it easier to force turnovers and set up short fields.
Offense would become more of a factor too because a team that can succeed on 4th down consistently would have an edge.

Also, you don't need to carry a punter on your roster, opening up spots for more depth at other positions.

I could see this rule hurting us in the division to be honest.
The Bengals seem to go on long stretches in the division where they can't move the ball.
It would be more entertaining though.

Thoughts?

[SunsetBengal]

(08-08-2024, 03:47 PM)Bengalstripes9 Wrote: I don't mind the new kickoff rule, but I could see some issues with offsides being called/not called when it should be.

I actually think it would make the game more interesting to do away with kickoffs and punts and force teams to go for it on 4th down.

It would make the game more entertaining.
Defense would become more of a factor because it makes it easier to force turnovers and set up short fields.
Offense would become more of a factor too because a team that can succeed on 4th down consistently would have an edge.

Also, you don't need to carry a punter on your roster, opening up spots for more depth at other positions.

I could see this rule hurting us in the division to be honest.
The Bengals seem to go on long stretches in the division where they can't move the ball.
It would be more entertaining though.

Thoughts?

I cannot agree with you on doing away with the kicking aspect of the game. To me those are opportunities for exciting and momentum changing plays to happen. They have amended the plays enough for sake of safety in regard to the high speed collisions that caused so many injuries, let's see if they keep the foot in football.

[Bengalstripes9]

(08-08-2024, 04:08 PM)SunsetBengal Wrote: I cannot agree with you on doing away with the kicking aspect of the game. To me those are opportunities for exciting and momentum changing plays to happen. They have amended the plays enough for sake of safety in regard to the high speed collisions that caused so many injuries, let's see if they keep the foot in football.

I guess I'm more on the indifferent side.

I think it would be more exciting to force teams to go for it.

But I don't mind kickoffs/punts either. There are some entertaining kickoffs once in awhile in terms of onside kicks and house calls.

If I do have a stance, it is to make the game as straight-forward as possible and limit the potential for confusion.
A lot of rules recently add more confusion into the game (for example, what is and isn't a catch, the hip drop tackle, etc.).

I'm not sure why they even call it football to be honest. 
There was already a sport with the same name for one.
And two, the game is primarily played with your hands.
I always wondered why they didn't just call it soccer instead of changing the name of football to soccer, and then taking the name football.
Or they could have come up with another name.
To me it seems like the game takes a lot from Rugby, and has a lot of concepts in it that make it like war.
Maybe a name that has something to do with war would fit better.
At the same time, stealing the name of another game and calling it your own is very fitting for a game that is similar to war metaphorically.

It's an incredibly brutal game with a high likelihood of injury.
To go away from the physical aspect of the game goes against the original design of the game.
I think the NFL should just own up to it being a dangerous sport like the UFC does.

[J24]

(08-08-2024, 05:49 PM)Bengalstripes9 Wrote: I guess I'm more on the indifferent side.

I think it would be more exciting to force teams to go for it.

But I don't mind kickoffs/punts either. There are some entertaining kickoffs once in awhile in terms of onside kicks and house calls.

If I do have a stance, it is to make the game as straight-forward as possible and limit the potential for confusion.
A lot of rules recently add more confusion into the game (for example, what is and isn't a catch, the hip drop tackle, etc.).

I'm not sure why they even call it football to be honest. 
There was already a sport with the same name for one.
And two, the game is primarily played with your hands.
I always wondered why they didn't just call it soccer instead of changing the name of football to soccer, and then taking the name football.
Or they could have come up with another name.
To me it seems like the game takes a lot from Rugby, and has a lot of concepts in it that make it like war.
Maybe a name that has something to do with war would fit better.
At the same time, stealing the name of another game and calling it your own is very fitting for a game that is similar to war metaphorically.

It's an incredibly brutal game with a high likelihood of injury.
To go away from the physical aspect of the game goes against the original design of the game.
I think the NFL should just own up to it being a dangerous sport like the UFC does.

Sigh, 
They call it football  because the game  comes from both Rugby and association football(soccer). All three sports are properly called football. 

[Bengalstripes9]

(08-10-2024, 02:57 PM)J24 Wrote: Sigh, 
They call it football  because the game  comes from both Rugby and association football(soccer). All three sports are properly called football. 

They call rugby football?

I never heard that before.

Why on earth would they call 3 different sports the same thing?

Then again, the english language is very much like that. 

[J24]

(08-12-2024, 12:32 PM)Bengalstripes9 Wrote: They call rugby football?

I never heard that before.

Why on earth would they call 3 different sports the same thing?

Then again, the english language is very much like that. 

Yes it's called Rugby Football. There is actually 5 types of Football  Australian rules, Galic, Association, Rugby, and Gridiron(American).