Can anybody tell me why?

[*ochocincos*]

(10-07-2024, 04:20 PM)125250 Wrote: Shouldn’t he be fired, if it doesn’t? Means we are even worse than expected.

I feel like Anarumo is more in the hot seat than Taylor right now.

Taylor's conservative decision-making for the FG in the Ravens game is less of a fireable offense compared to how bad Anarumo's defense is performing.

[TheCincinnatiKid]

(10-07-2024, 04:29 PM)ochocincos Wrote: I feel like Anarumo is more in the hot seat than Taylor right now.

Taylor's conservative decision-making for the FG in the Ravens game is less of a fireable offense compared to how bad Anarumo's defense is performing.

The entire OT period doesn't happen if the defence makes a single stop in the 2nd half.

[*Wyche'sWarrior*]

(10-07-2024, 04:33 PM)TheCincinnatiKid Wrote: The entire OT period doesn't happen if the defence makes a single stop in the 2nd half.

Literally just one.

[*bengalfan74*]

(10-07-2024, 04:29 PM)ochocincos Wrote: I feel like Anarumo is more in the hot seat than Taylor right now.

Taylor's conservative decision-making for the FG in the Ravens game is less of a fireable offense compared to how bad Anarumo's defense is performing.

Absolutely

This defense is just awful and then some. We have like zero chance this season if somethings don't change and fast!

12 games left and we need to win like 11, at a minimum 10 of them to have any playoff chances. And you can't expect your offense to hang 35+ points a game all year. Especially when cold weather get here.

[*bengalfan74*]

(10-07-2024, 04:34 PM)Wyche Wrote: Literally just one.

520 yards

I'm not sure this D could beat a good High School Team ?

[NUGDUKWE]

(10-07-2024, 01:03 PM)casear2727 Wrote: Oline was starting to get abused, thus the threat of a sack or holding call.  Along with the pass rush coverage, pass defenders were jumping routes, see the Humphrey interception.

Zac called one run play to gain yards.  He called one pass play Burrow checked out of.

The 3rd down run was to align Evan for the FG.

I would love to have seen him take a shot with Chase 1 on 1, but that would be very risky.  

A shot with Chase 1 on 1 would be "very risky" Dude caught 10 of 12 targets for 193 yds and 2 touchdowns. What was our rushing stats in the 2nd half? Not good. I'm over the staff on both sides of the ball. The defense was terrible but when you absolutely gotta have they get us the ball. When you absolutely gotta have the offense gets us 2yds. I'll give Taylor credit he designs decent route concepts and there were some really good play designs yesterday. But the dude is worse than Marvin at situational football I keep hoping he'll learn and get better but he won't or can't. 

I'm not excusing the defense but how many times the last few years have we won games and said the defense won that because the offense couldn't finish. Feels like quite a few. This offense can't finish games. They completely disappeared at the end yesterday.

[*bfine32*]

I'm just spitballing here, but I'm gonna go out on a limb and say if we would have dropped back and took a sack, got a holding call, threw an INT the SAME folks asking why now would be asking why then.

Let me see if I can get it right:

Fire Zac immediately, we were already in FG range and Brown was averaging about 4 yards/carry. Feed Chase 3 times, get it closer, on the hash Mac wants, and kick the FG. Hell the conditions were perfect for a FG, Turner had just hit a 56 yarder.


How'd I do? 

[*ochocincos*]

(10-07-2024, 04:33 PM)TheCincinnatiKid Wrote: The entire OT period doesn't happen if the defence makes a single stop in the 2nd half.

100%

[Essex Johnson]

(10-07-2024, 12:52 PM)bengalfan74 Wrote: Why did we decide lets just kick a 50+ yard FG to try and win it?

We ran three offensive plays after we recovered the fumble at the Ravens 37 and got all the way down to the 35  

We ran all 3 plays from heavy sets. And not a single pass despite JB having an outstanding day!! On the 1st play the Ravens have 9 defenders in the box. Everyone of them crashes to the LOS at the snap. J. Chase has a very soft coverage.

A half second after the snap there's a wiidddddeeeeee open middle of the field. If Chase runs a quick slant and it was a play action fake to Brown it's probably a TD. At a minimum a good gain. Of course JB would have to throw quickly.

I just can't understand why you have Joe Burrow for crying out friggin loud! And the coaches say screw that, put the Lamborghini away, lets get out the Honda civic and just get a couple yards a try a long FG.

And this isn't the first time ZT and Co. have been guilty of this. ML 2.0

Ravens were getting more pressure on Burrow it seemed towards end of regulation, Burrow was sacked last series but I would have passed on 2nd down, we get nothing, i then would have run the ball on 3rd down, I am also questioning how can we get 3 yards on 3 carries, minimum we should have had 6 to 8 yards... 

[casear2727]

(10-07-2024, 05:50 PM)bfine32 Wrote: I'm just spitballing here, but I'm gonna go out on a limb and say if we would have dropped back and took a sack, got a holding call, threw an INT the SAME folks asking why now would be asking why then.

Let me see if I can get it right:

Fire Zac immediately, we were already in FG range and Brown was averaging about 4 yards/carry. Feed Chase 3 times, get it closer, on the hash Mac wants, and kick the FG. Hell the conditions were perfect for a FG, Turner had just hit a 56 yarder.


How'd I do? 

Good Take.

[casear2727]

(10-07-2024, 06:27 PM)Essex Johnson Wrote: Ravens were getting more pressure on Burrow it seemed towards end of regulation, Burrow was sacked last series but I would have passed on 2nd down, we get nothing, i then would have run the ball on 3rd down, I am also questioning how can we get 3 yards on 3 carries, minimum we should have had 6 to 8 yards... 

It is this crazy thing called MATH.  More defenders than blockers.  Weird, I know....

[matmaven]

(10-07-2024, 12:52 PM)bengalfan74 Wrote: Why did we decide lets just kick a 50+ yard FG to try and win it?

We ran three offensive plays after we recovered the fumble at the Ravens 37 and got all the way down to the 35

We ran all 3 plays from heavy sets. And not a single pass despite JB having an outstanding day!! On the 1st play the Ravens have 9 defenders in the box. Everyone of them crashes to the LOS at the snap. J. Chase has a very soft coverage.

A half second after the snap there's a wiidddddeeeeee open middle of the field. If Chase runs a quick slant and it was a play action fake to Brown it's probably a TD. At a minimum a good gain. Of course JB would have to throw quickly.

I just can't understand why you have Joe Burrow for crying out friggin loud! And the coaches say screw that, put the Lamborghini away, lets get out the Honda civic and just get a couple yards a try a long FG.

And this isn't the first time ZT and Co. have been guilty of this. ML 2.0

If you can’t trust your offensive line to protect long enough for a quick throw and can’t trust the QB you’re paying a gazillion dollars to make good decisions and you can’t trust your two premium WR who want to be paid like superstars to catch the ball then you’ve already lost. You have these superstar skill players who have made plays all game and then with the game on the line you run 3 Pee Wee football dive plays.

Even if you want to run the ball three time - running them all out of heavy sets where you are basically holding up a sign that says “we’re going to run and we are playing for a 50+ yard FG” is beyond dumb. If Burrow checked out of a pass, exactly what look were they looking for from them defense in the heavy formation they were in.

The decision making was absolutely mind-boggling to me. It was playing not to lose plain and simple.

[casear2727]

(10-07-2024, 06:53 PM)matmaven Wrote: If you can’t trust your offensive line to protect long enough for a quick throw and can’t trust the QB you’re paying a gazillion dollars to make good decisions and you can’t trust your two premium WR who want to be paid like superstars to catch the ball then you’ve already lost.  You have these superstar skill players who have made plays all game and then with the game on the line you run 3 Pee Wee football dive plays.  

Even if you want to run the ball three time - running them all out of heavy sets where you are basically holding up a sign that says “we’re going to run and we are playing for a 50+ yard FG” is beyond dumb. If Burrow checked out of a pass, exactly what look were they looking for from them defense in the heavy formation they were in.  

The decision making was absolutely mind-boggling to me. It was playing not to lose plain and simple.

This is not the first time we have seen Zac pucker up at the end of games.

[TKUHL]

(10-07-2024, 12:52 PM)bengalfan74 Wrote: Why did we decide lets just kick a 50+ yard FG to try and win it?

We ran three offensive plays after we recovered the fumble at the Ravens 37 and got all the way down to the 35

We ran all 3 plays from heavy sets. And not a single pass despite JB having an outstanding day!! On the 1st play the Ravens have 9 defenders in the box. Everyone of them crashes to the LOS at the snap. J. Chase has a very soft coverage.

A half second after the snap there's a wiidddddeeeeee open middle of the field. If Chase runs a quick slant and it was a play action fake to Brown it's probably a TD. At a minimum a good gain. Of course JB would have to throw quickly.

I just can't understand why you have Joe Burrow for crying out friggin loud! And the coaches say screw that, put the Lamborghini away, lets get out the Honda civic and just get a couple yards a try a long FG.

And this isn't the first time ZT and Co. have been guilty of this. ML 2.0

That’s the million dollar question. Once I saw us trying to run up the middle not even trying to put the game away I turned it off. Can’t stand how conservative Zac gets in situations like that. It’s Zac’s patented Prevent Offense. So done with it.

[THE PISTONS]

(10-07-2024, 01:06 PM)SunsetBengal Wrote: It did seem rather strange. If they knew that all they wanted to accomplish was to put the ball in the center of the field, they should have kicked on 2nd down. That way if an emergency happens (like a bad hold) they just need to cover the ball and live on.

I think on 2nd down they were further back. They gained a small amount of yards on the runs.

Which begs the question, why not do a short screen to Chase? High percentage and he gains yards.

[GodFather]

"… Every time I try to walk away
Something makes me turn around and stay
And I can't tell you why"

[Destro]

My other thing is you have Chase one on one against a rookie. You have Joe Burrow as the QB. You don't even try? Now, if it was Browning or something, yeah, I get it. But Joe is smart enough to know, you take the high percentage throw, if you got it. If not, throw it away. Gain zero, lose zero. Same as a run crashing into the line, but this has a higher likelihood of gaining long yardage.

[*bfine32*]

(10-07-2024, 07:57 PM)Destro Wrote: My other thing is you have Chase one on one against a rookie. You have Joe Burrow as the QB. You don't even try? Now, if it was Browning or something, yeah, I get it. But Joe is smart enough to know, you take the high percentage throw, if you got it. If not, throw it away. Gain zero, lose zero. Same as a run crashing into the line, but this has a higher likelihood of gaining long yardage.

Why is reality SO HARD for folks to understand?

It has been brought up numerous times that Zac called a pass play on the first down in OT, JB checked out of it, because HE wanted to run.

OK, let's pretend that never happened so we can continue to hate on Zac. "Well why the hell didn't Zac call a pass on the next 2 plays? "

IDK maybe his QB had already indicated he's more comfortable running in that situation because he's already checked out of a pass.

So why not call plays resigned to run if the QB is more comfortable with running and if the QB sees something to want him to check out of a pass, HE can do it.

We're in Bizarro world this team just scored 38 points against one of the best Defenses in the NFL and the board is littered with armchair QBs questioning the play calling. 

[reuben.ahmed]

Tell me why
I never wanna hear you say
I want it that way

[matmaven]

(10-07-2024, 09:28 PM)bfine32 Wrote: Why is reality SO HARD for folks to understand?

It has been brought up numerous times that Zac called a pass play on the first down in OT, JB checked out of it, because HE wanted to run.

OK, let's pretend that never happened so we can continue to hate on Zac. "Well why the hell didn't Zac call a pass on the next 2 plays? "

IDK maybe his QB had already indicated he's more comfortable running in that situation because he's already checked out of a pass.

So why not call plays resigned to run if the QB is more comfortable with running and if the QB sees something to want him to check out of a pass, HE can do it.

We're in Bizarro world this team just scored 38 points against one of the best Defenses in the NFL and the board is littered with armchair QBs questioning the play calling. 

Burrow checked out of a first down pass so that means he doesn't want to throw the ball on 2nd or 3rd down?  A first down pass play BTW from a 3 TE tight formation.  Talk about bizarro world.

Taylor played not to lose.  He deserves every single bit of criticism he is getting.  The team is 1-4 and headed absolutely nowhere.