Rank Our QBs (2025)

[CottonHill]

I am going to put him at 2, but he has to stay healthy and cant throw 3 or 4 games away to start the season. The guys behind him are to good.
Mahomes- he gets the nod due to his super bowls and some insane plays in the crunchiest of times.....but he has been bailed out by officiating time after time and i feel like the boiling point hit this year in the AFC champ game and i think his best days are behind him. He will still be elite for a while just not magical
Joe
Josh
Lamar

[*Nate (formerly eliminate08)*]

(05-08-2025, 08:49 AM)Synric Wrote: This is tough for me as a film junkie.

Instantly everyone says Patrick Mahomes because of team success or Lama Jackson because of the MVP from stats... but if you put on the film you realize no one is playing the QB position at a higher level than Joe Burrow.

Truth. Joe reads Defenses better than anyone and is the most accurate by far. He even put up the best stats last year on top of it, he had one 
of the best seasons a QB has ever had. Just sucks it got squandered. Also Goff is being overlooked here, he had a much better year than Josh 
Allen IMO.

[*bfine32*]

PK and Milz are doing their annual QB preseason rankings and did the AFC East and North today.

The max a player can get is:
Starter: 12
Backup: 5
Developmental: 3

3 Teams got 17
BUF
BAl
CIN

I didn't hear BUF's breakdown, but Cincy had:
Starter:12
Backup: 4
Dev:1

BAL got 12,5,0

[*bfine32*]

(05-08-2025, 08:49 AM)Synric Wrote: This is tough for me as a film junkie.

Instantly everyone says Patrick Mahomes because of team success or Lama Jackson because of the MVP from stats... but if you put on the film you realize no one is playing the QB position at a higher level than Joe Burrow.

Are you saying Joe is playing at a higher level than LaMarr? 

Joe is great, but LaMarr is a unicorn. 

[Speedy Thomas]

The best clutch QB in the NFL with a proven backup deserves to be ranked at the top.

https://www.si.com/nfl/bengals/allbengals-insiders-plus/look-joe-burrow-top-nfl-quarterback-in-fourth-quarters-when-trailing-01jtp9t1tczw

[Sled21]

(05-01-2025, 03:08 PM)TheLeonardLeap Wrote: You watched a multi-time MVP QB go to his 7th AFCC game and 5th SB in in his 7 years of starting and that was your takeaway?

Burrow is great and I voted 2-3, but regardless of how you feel about him all Mahomes does is win.

This is about the QB's, not the teams winning record. Mahomes is a better athlete, but Joe is a better QB.