Any complaints this week about Fat Randy?

[*TheLeonardLeap*]

(11-27-2017, 09:09 AM)Sled21 Wrote: Y'all raise up off the Nuge. He was a good kicker for a long time for us. He's gone now, no need to keep bashing him.

...but he wasn't? Nugent played for the Bengals from '10 to '16, and these were his FG% rankings...

'10: 21st
'11: 8th  (he had 14 FGs of 20-29 yards, aka shorter than a current PAT, and 0 attempts of 50+ that year)
'12: 20th
'13: 23rd
'14: 27th
'15: 23rd
'16: 24th

So the only year he wasn't a clearly below average kicker for the Bengals was the year he kicked a ton of PAT-FGs and didn't even bothering to attempt 50+.

He was actually really quite a bad kicker his entire Bengals career. I don't feel the need to keep bashing him for it, but I can't stay silent while people are calling his tenure with the Bengals "good".

[Air Force 1]

Elliot is not hurt..

[sandwedge]

I still cringe when we have to kick FGs or XPTs.....

[*ochocincos*]

(11-26-2017, 08:50 PM)Go Cards Wrote: Nope had a doughnut on him today even.

Hope he stays solid because really do not want to have to use another draft pick on a kicker.

Way bigger needs.

I don't think that's necessary even if the Bengals do want to get another kicker. There will be kickers to get as UDFA. If the Bengals REALLY want to get a K though in the draft, wait until the 6th or 7th round. Heck, there isn't a K I'd consider drafting at all besides maybe Carlson, but he's had quite a few misses this year that I think he's available after the 5th round.

[snowy]

I didn't have a problem with Bullock in the first place. Lawd knows I have problems with the Bengals and their ways of doing things, but Bullock ain't one of them.

[McC]

Yes. I have a complaint. He's too fat. If only he had access to any kind of workout equipment. Or cared.

[*jason*]

No problem with him on 11/26/17, but he will cost the Bengals a win vs the Steelers this week. I've already posted it in the prediction thread. Let it be written. Let it be done.

[snowy]

McC Wrote:Yes.  I have a complaint.  He's too fat.  If only he had access to any kind of workout equipment.  Or cared.

Any man with a belly like that who can get his leg up that high has my whole-hearted admiration.

[*Awful Llama*]

(11-27-2017, 01:19 PM)TheLeonardLeap Wrote: ...but he wasn't? Nugent played for the Bengals from '10 to '16, and these were his FG% rankings...

'10: 21st
'11: 8th  (he had 14 FGs of 20-29 yards, aka shorter than a current PAT, and 0 attempts of 50+ that year)
'12: 20th
'13: 23rd
'14: 27th
'15: 23rd
'16: 24th

So the only year he wasn't a clearly below average kicker for the Bengals was the year he kicked a ton of PAT-FGs and didn't even bothering to attempt 50+.

He was actually really quite a bad kicker his entire Bengals career. I don't feel the need to keep bashing him for it, but I can't stay silent while people are calling his tenure with the Bengals "good".

Yeah, he wasn't that good, so if pointing that out is bashing him, then I guess I'll keep on bashing him.  One big point in his favor: when he did screw up we weren't subjected to his braying sister shrieking at his critics.  Yep, I'm looking at you, Shank.

[*TheLeonardLeap*]

(11-27-2017, 07:39 PM)McC Wrote: Yes.  I have a complaint.  He's too fat.  If only he had access to any kind of workout equipment.  Or cared.

Kickers:


..and yet they'll still play into their 40s.

[Beaker]

(11-27-2017, 08:12 PM)jason Wrote: No problem with him on 11/26/17, but he will cost the Bengals a win vs the Steelers this week. I've already posted it in the prediction thread. Let it be written. Let it be done.

Love that positive vibe youre putting out there.

[*Nate (formerly eliminate08)*]

No complaints this week and overall this season. Need to make those extra points though.