(03-27-2020, 02:34 PM)spazz70 Wrote: BTW...in the original Tecmo bowl the 1988 Bengals were a tough team even with the Bo Jackson glitch...Fulcher could chase him doen
For sure dude, Fulcher was a gem in the game. One dude on defense could dominate.
(03-27-2020, 07:51 PM)TecmoBengals Wrote: It's a media outlet using the Madden game to sim a tournament of franchise GOATS since they don't have real sports to cover.
It's hard to rate an all time team. Do you rate the players on their dominance during their time period? Careers? Or how they'd translate into today's nfl? If you do how they played during their era, there would be too many 95+ overalls I'd believe. As many of these players are HoF players I'd imagine they were top 5 at their postition for most of their career.
That being said I do think Anderson, Akins, Chad, Willie are all underrated or other comparable players from other teams are overrated. Also how is Jackson rated as high as hall? That's an odd rating to me
Carl Pickens should be ahead of both TJ and Collinsworth.
Takeo Spikes > Vontaze Butfict. No contest.
Corey Dillon should be rated higher IMO. If you take into account of the teams he played on for the bulk of his career, then it's all that more remarkable. What he did here, for those that actually saw and remember it, was pretty amazing.
The fact that William Jackson is on here is absolutely ridiculous. Joseph was far superior to both him and Hall.
(03-30-2020, 12:33 PM)Wes Mantooth Wrote: Carl Pickens should be ahead of both TJ and Collinsworth.
Takeo Spikes > Vontaze Butfict. No contest.
Corey Dillon should be rated higher IMO. If you take into account of the teams he played on for the bulk of his career, then it's all that more remarkable. What he did here, for those that actually saw and remember it, was pretty amazing.
The fact that William Jackson is on here is absolutely ridiculous. Joseph was far superior to both him and Hall.
I'd argue that both Tory James and Deltha O'Neill should be there before either of them.
Should Icky or Lorenzo Neal show up at FB?
What about Brian Simmons and James Francis at LB?
Why is Krumrie ranked so low?
Why does every other team have a kicker and punter, but we don't? Who would be our special teams guys? Huber? Graham? Breech?
(03-30-2020, 12:33 PM)Wes Mantooth Wrote: Carl Pickens should be ahead of both TJ and Collinsworth.
Takeo Spikes > Vontaze Butfict. No contest.
Corey Dillon should be rated higher IMO. If you take into account of the teams he played on for the bulk of his career, then it's all that more remarkable. What he did here, for those that actually saw and remember it, was pretty amazing.
The fact that William Jackson is on here is absolutely ridiculous. Joseph was far superior to both him and Hall.
There is hope for the Bengals in this Madden GOAT Franchise Sim. Yesterday's results:
Panthers beat Falcons (McCaffrey with the OT TD run)
Redskins beat Cowboys (Sammy Baugh with a a game winning drive for the Redskins)
Patriots beat Dolphins
Jaguars beat Colts (goes to show you video game land is different)
nevertheless!
![[Image: 4CV0TeR.png]](https://i.imgur.com/4CV0TeR.png)
