11-06-2015, 04:59 PM
(11-06-2015, 04:52 PM)Shake n Blake Wrote: Lol. Rep.
To be more specific, when there used to be Cam vs Andy debates. Then rush TD's were discussed. If we were talking positively about Dalton's rush numbers, then rush TD's were to be disregarded.
That's a bit misleading.
It's not just Andy, and it's not just Cam.
If a QB is a dual threat player, you often get into their rushing ability as a reason why they're great/good/not good or whatever the argument is. You don't really talk much about rushing yards, TDs, and whatnot with guys that aren't that type of QB. It is however, acceptable to bring up total TDs, but it "means more" to a lot of people when it's not a bunch of QB sneaks from the 1 after the guy doesn't rush for anything on the drive beforehand. Brady's TD sneaks are less impressive than Kaepernick's scrambles, but we all know who is clearly the better QB.
If we were discussing Russell Wilson vs Matt Ryan, you may want to bring up Wilson's ability on the ground that makes up for his lack of what Ryan has in the arm, but it's not trying to say that Ryan's rushing stats should be totally disregarded, just that they don't mean as much when it's likely just some QB sneaks from the 1 for his rushing TDs.
Andy is a bit different now because last year and also this year he has shown some ability on the ground that is somewhat impressive.
Let's not pretend that Andy's rushing ability was worth bringing up against Cam back when those arguments happened (around 2011-2013).
