Carson/Chad, Dalton/Green or Burrow/Chase

[Nicomo Cosca]

(01-03-2022, 06:18 PM)fredtoast Wrote: That is all I have to work with.

Randy Moss averaged 19.0 yards per reception his rookie season and then never did it again in his entire career.  Robert Griffen III finished 3rd in the league with a 102 passer rating his rookie season.

All I can do is compere the best I have seen from both players.

I mean, this is the sheer definition of cherry picking one stat to fit an argument. To suggest Moss didn’t greatly improve after his rookie season would be absurd. He had a 1600 yard season at 26. He also ofc went on to have that insane year with Brady where he had 23 TD’s (still a record). I don’t think there’s any reasonable argument to be made that he peaked as a rookie.