02-18-2022, 09:04 PM
(02-18-2022, 08:41 PM)TheLeonardLeap Wrote: Finley isn't even in the league anymore because he wasn't even an NFL-caliber backup. He's just bad at (NFL level) football. As for Brandon Allen and Andy Dalton, rather than do all that math you only needed a couple numbers...
Andy Dalton Bengals Sack%: 6.6 (that's from 2016-2019 only, it was 5.3 from 2011-2015)
Brandon Allen Bengals Sack%: 5.9
Joe Burrow Bengals Sack%: 8.2
That's a significant different, Shake. One that can't be easily waved away from there just being one source of problem.
- - - - - - - -
Andrew Luck's mentality led the Colts to the playoffs his first 3 years in the league, including to the AFC Championship game... it doesn't change the fact that it ended his career. Burrow's had a completely rebuilt knee in year 1 and now an MCL sprain in the other that's taken him down screaming in pain multiple times that he had to play on for 2 months in year 2.
Keep his mentality if you're fine with only 5 years of Joe Burrow. Change his mentality at least some if you actually want 15-20 years of Joe Burrow.
- - - - - -- - -
...and this is coming from a guy who's been among the loudest for years about needing to fix the OL, so you know this isn't me scapegoating Burrow or anything Shake. These two matters of the OL being awful and Burrow needing to change aren't mutually exclusive.
I am also a build inside-out guy that was on Team Sewell, but you also might want to factor in that Andy had one of the quickest releases with timing patterns and dump offs, Brandon is a runner, and Joe is a downfield pocket passer. Their different styles will increase and decrease the probability of sack numbers if the line has consistently been playing at about the same. But I agree Joe's playstyle + current OL talent = Andrew Luck, if there is little to no change.