12-26-2015, 05:10 PM
(12-26-2015, 04:59 PM)wildcats forever Wrote: Maybe not. McElroy left the Jets with concussion and ankle issues, then after a year on our practice squad. retired without taking a game snap. We'll never know what he could do because of physical limitations.
Maybe my positive view of AJM's potential to do well Monday is upsetting, but logic doesn't always prevail. It's only my opinion, though I have seen proof of this in my lifetime. And this is how I can support my team for our next game.
It's not the positive view.
It's the logic behind it.
If you truly want to apply this logic you have to accept that he lost the last 2 games of his senior year (also the 2 biggest games of that year).
Saying he performed in big games at Alabama and that means he will in Cincinnati is fallacy.
Andy Dalton was known as a big game QB who was clutch at TCU.
AJ McCarron was never really an underdog at Bama.
Andy Dalton was always the underdog with TCU.
If you want to discuss actual reasons why there is positive views to be had, that's fine.
