09-19-2023, 07:05 PM
(09-19-2023, 06:28 PM)Joelist Wrote: PFF and QBR both have big issues.
QBR is used by no one but ESPN and it lost its luster pretty quick with nonsense like claiming Terrell Pryor was a better QB than Drew Brees or Tim Tebow better than Aaron Rodgers....
PFF scores are basically secret sauce nonsense. I agree with the player quoted upthread - coaches ignore PFF and grade the players themselves based on the situation and their assignment. PFF has become the "Geekbench" of the NFL alas....
I think you got these backwards a little bit. We know how PFF grades are formulated, but QBR is has proprietary formula that is a "secret sauce". It's based on EPA to some level, I think.