Greatest Bengal RB of all time

[Sled21]

(01-08-2024, 11:35 AM)TecmoBengals Wrote: How's it not close?

Dillon rushed for 8,061 yards in 107 games. Brooks rushed for 6,447 yards in 118 games. Dillon rushed for more TDs (45) compared to Brooks (37). Dillon (20) fumbled less than Brooks (37).

There are stats favoring Brooks (4.8) such as Y/A compared to Dillon's (4.3). I'm good with anyone voting Brooks as I almost did so myself, but the two talents are "close" for debating who is the RB1 on a Bengals all-time team.

Because I watched them both play and IMO, which is what this thread is about... opinions.... Brooks was a much better RB than Dillon. Dillon was a more punishing runner, but Brooks was so smooth.