Ranking all players on the roster prior to 2025 off season

[Whatever]

(Yesterday, 12:28 PM)CJD Wrote: The premise was best to worst. Potential plays a big role in the quality of a player. If you'd prefer, we can reframe it to "important" or "impact" players. Ryan Rehko is a great player, but he's also a punter. Much like you wouldn't draft a punter in the first round even if he's the best punter in the world, his positional value causes him to fall down the rankings.

Obviously, you're not a fan of my method of ranking players. You're free to create your list and we can discuss that, if you'd like.

If it's "important" or "impact" players, shouldn't the guy that led the team in Interceptions and turnovers be higher than 38th?  

It just honestly feels like you threw the names out in the order you personally like them, then are rationalizing after the fact to justify their spots.  But the logic doesn't stay consistent and falls apart.  That's the issue.  Your methodology is inconsistent.

I agree to disagree.