Ranking all players on the roster prior to 2025 off season

[Whatever]

(01-22-2025, 11:15 AM)CJD Wrote: Geno has a chance to be on this team next year.

Bell does not. He was pretty clearly washed this season.

Moss also has a very small chance of being on this roster in 2024.

I have a hard time ranking back up players that will almost certainly not be on this team above a player who the Bengals have a decent shot at keeping for 2025. Stone actually had a decent end to the year. Good enough that I think the next DC may give him a chance (with competition) to start next season.

I agree with your edit, which was my entire point in making this list (the talent drop off after the top ~10 is insane), but Whatever kind of threw the entire thread into disarray by implying my ranking of Yoshi indicates I love him like a brother.

What does the odds of a guy being on the team next year have to do with how good/bad they played, their impact/importance, or their talent level?

You're getting overly focused on one issue that's been pointed out when this list overall is pretty poor.